Ex-Gay Christian Wins Case Against Malta’s Conversion Practices Law

Malta’s Landmark Ruling: Ex-Gay Christian Cleared of Conversion Therapy Charges

In a pivotal decision, Malta’s courts have acquitted Matthew Grech, a Christian previously accused of promoting conversion practices. This outcome concludes a protracted three-year legal dispute and prompts renewed discussion on the nation’s stance on conversion therapy laws.

Outside the courthouse, Grech expressed relief and emphasized the importance of freedom of speech and religion. “Christians should be free to share their testimonies, share what God has done in their lives, share their views around sexuality and gender, and share the Word of God freely without a sense of intimidation, fear [or] bullying,” he declared.

Grech further stated, “The Maltese courts have decided for freedom of speech, for freedom of religion, and we’re just really thankful that finally we can look at a future where we can see the restoration of a healthy discussion, a healthy debate around sexuality and gender. And the truth is: transformation, change, is real, it is possible, and it is time to bring the discussion to the table again.”

The charges stemmed from a 2022 interview on PMnews Malta where Grech discussed his departure from homosexuality and the potential benefits of therapy for those with undesired same-sex attractions. Malta’s Affirmation of Sexual Orientation, Gender, and Gender Expression Act, enacted in 2016, prohibits any efforts aimed at altering sexual orientation or gender identity.

Facing possible imprisonment and fines, Grech’s trial saw multiple delays, with the final verdict being postponed several times before the ‘not guilty’ ruling was delivered. Following the verdict, Grech took to Instagram, stating, “It’s a victory! Praise you Jesus!” and urged the Maltese government and the European Commission to repeal conversion therapy laws.

Grech’s case, supported by Andrea Williams, CEO of the Christian Legal Centre (CLC), has sparked international interest. Williams praised the decision as a triumph for free speech and Christian testimony, stating, “Today’s acquittal sends an unmistakable message: attempts to criminalise Christian teaching and testimony will not stand.”

The verdict also exonerated two PMnews journalists who were prosecuted alongside Grech. The CLC celebrated this as a “win for freedom of the press.” Mrs. Williams criticized the term ‘conversion therapy’ as “an undefined, politically loaded term” used unjustly against Grech.

Dr. Mike Davidson, Chair of the International Federation for Therapeutic and Counselling Choice, supported the court’s decision, emphasizing the importance of free speech regarding personal experiences. “We remain committed to upholding professional standards, lawful dialogue, and careful engagement on matters that are often deeply personal and complex,” he stated.

Malta’s initial ban on conversion therapy set a precedent, influencing similar legislation in other countries like the UK and Australia. The outcome of this case is expected to have significant implications for international discussions surrounding conversion practices and freedom of expression.