Date Posted: 2024-11-21 17:48:23 | Video Duration: 00:47:18
In an era characterized by increasing secularization and pluralism, the possibility of meaningful dialogue between Christians and non-Christians often seems challenging. However, broadcaster Justin Brierley offers a path forward. With nearly two decades dedicated to facilitating debates between Christians, atheists, and agnostics, his international radio show and podcast “Unbelievable” has become a platform for such conversations.
The Genesis of “Unbelievable”
Justin Brierley began his journey in Christian radio in 2005, aiming to serve UK Christians who were often overlooked by mainstream media. While the station excelled in delivering Christian content, Brierley noticed a gap: the lack of modeled conversations between Christians and their non-Christian counterparts. Given the secular backdrop of UK culture, he felt it was crucial to initiate dialogues with guests of differing beliefs. Thus, the concept of “Unbelievable” was born, questioning whether the claims of Christianity were indeed “unbelievable.”
Over 17 years of hosting these discussions, Brierley found that Christianity is not only reasonable but that open-ended conversations serve as a valuable tool for exploring its core tenets. The show’s transition to podcasting and video attracted a diverse audience, including skeptics and seekers, making it a bipartisan platform for genuine exchanges.
Challenges and Triumphs in Dialogue
Launching a platform for such dialogues was not without its challenges. Brierley faced pushback from some listeners who questioned the need for atheist perspectives on a Christian radio station. However, he argued that Christians in a secular society must be open to hearing opposing views. He emphasized the importance of exposing Christians to arguments against their faith in a setting where they could also hear robust Christian responses.
Despite initial resistance, many Christians embraced the opportunity to witness authentic conversations. Brierley highlighted the importance of not only presenting apologetic information but also demonstrating how to engage in meaningful dialogue. This approach, he believed, was crucial for both Christians and non-Christians in understanding each other’s perspectives.
The Art of Civil Conversation
Through his experiences, Brierley learned that the key to maintaining civil dialogue lies in the selection of participants and the moderation of discussions. He acknowledged that, at times, conversations became heated due to the combative nature of the participants. However, he emphasized the importance of finding common ground and moving discussions forward when they reached an impasse.
He also stressed the value of “steelmanning” arguments—presenting an opponent’s position as strongly as possible before countering it. This approach fosters an environment where both sides feel heard and respected, reducing the likelihood of conversations devolving into hostility.
Impact and Influence
While guest perspectives rarely shifted within the span of an hour-long episode, the broader impact was evident among listeners. Brierley received feedback from many who transitioned from skepticism to curiosity or even belief over time. These transformations were often the result of prolonged exposure to the thoughtful and respectful exchanges on “Unbelievable.”
In the context of his conversations and his recent book, “The Surprising Rebirth of Belief in God,” Brierley noted a shift in the tone of religious and secular dialogues. The aggressive atheism of past decades has given way to more nuanced discussions, with secular thinkers increasingly recognizing the value of faith and its contributions to society.
Lessons for Broader Application
Brierley believes that the principles of humanizing opponents and engaging in respectful dialogue can extend beyond religious debates. He suggests that these approaches could help bridge divides within society and even within the church, where political and ideological differences often create rifts.
Ultimately, Brierley’s work underscores the power of conversation as a tool for understanding and transformation. By fostering an environment of openness and respect, he has helped create spaces where meaningful dialogue can flourish.
Watch the Original Video on Youtube
